Page 2 of 6

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 16:10
by Linkaday
O&O offers a Migration Suite (and if my memory serves me well - Paragon too) that claims to workaround the limitations of WET and migrate applications as well.

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 19:27
by nas8e9
Linkaday wrote:O&O offers a Migration Suite (and if my memory serves me well - Paragon too) that claims to workaround the limitations of WET and migrate applications as well.
Paragon System Upgrade Utilities 2010 and also Laplink PCmover. I have no experience with either.

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 19:48
by mwb1100
FWIW (very little, I imagine), when I'm upgrading an OS I generally avoid using an upgrade install or other automatic migration of applications. I usually take it as an opportunity to just restart fresh and reinstall my applications as I need them. I figure (rightly or wrongly) that this will get rid of most of the cruft in the registry and file system that has likely accumulated over the years (more accurately: avoid pulling that cruft over to the new OS installation).

But there's no question, it's more work and time.

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 20:02
by admin
Thanks for the migration software tips and general tips!!
mwb1100 wrote:FWIW (very little, I imagine), when I'm upgrading an OS I generally avoid using an upgrade install or other automatic migration of applications. I usually take it as an opportunity to just restart fresh and reinstall my applications as I need them. I figure (rightly or wrongly) that this will get rid of most of the cruft in the registry and file system that has likely accumulated over the years (more accurately: avoid pulling that cruft over to the new OS installation).

But there's no question, it's more work and time.
Same here, but in my case it's a LOT more work and time. I would go for a migration software if I knew it's good. But I don't see any with a good enough reputation to actually trust it so far as to allow to play with the bowels of my next OS...

Thank god there are at least some good portable applications on my system... :wink:

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 20:38
by zer0
Confirmed: it is possible to save a WET file onto another internal HDD so it should be piece of cake, except for the apps ;)

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 09 Nov 2009 21:53
by admin
zer0 wrote:Confirmed: it is possible to save a WET file onto another internal HDD so it should be piece of cake, except for the apps ;)
Cool, thanks for checking!

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 10 Nov 2009 13:57
by PeterH
admin wrote:Thanks for the migration software tips and general tips!!
mwb1100 wrote:FWIW (very little, I imagine), when I'm upgrading an OS I generally avoid using an upgrade install or other automatic migration of applications. I usually take it as an opportunity to just restart fresh and reinstall my applications as I need them. I figure (rightly or wrongly) that this will get rid of most of the cruft in the registry and file system that has likely accumulated over the years (more accurately: avoid pulling that cruft over to the new OS installation).

But there's no question, it's more work and time.
Same here, but in my case it's a LOT more work and time. I would go for a migration software if I knew it's good. But I don't see any with a good enough reputation to actually trust it so far as to allow to play with the bowels of my next OS...

Thank god there are at least some good portable applications on my system... :wink:
It's exactly as mwb1100 said...

...and as you keep you XP running: are you in a hurry to prepare 7 for all these old functions? If not: in your place I would prefer the clean install.

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 13 Nov 2009 09:35
by admin
Update of my state of mind:

I will get myself a completely new computer with Win7 Prof 64, plus a bag of drugs to get through installing and configuring about 200 softwares. :mrgreen:

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 01:08
by nas8e9
admin wrote:Update of my state of mind:

I will get myself a completely new computer with Win7 Prof 64, plus a bag of drugs to get through installing and configuring about 200 softwares. :mrgreen:
I'm not equipped to give pharmaceutical advice, but as far as processors are concerned it might be useful to get one with Intel's or AMD's hardware virtualization feature. Microsoft's Windows Virtual PC requires it and it enables (when run on Windows 7 Professional or Ultimate) running Windows XP Mode, a free and fully licensed copy of Windows XP that's ready to run (no Windows XP setup required).

As far as I know, Intel's Core 2 Duo 8xxx and Quad 9xxx as well as the Core i5 and i7 models support Intel Virtualization Technology; I *think* all of AMD's models support it. My personal preference would be an Intel Core i5 750 or even better, an Intel Core i7 860; unfortunately, processor "fan boys" can make for awkward threads (no pun intended) so I'll leave it at that. :wink:

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 08:23
by admin
nas8e9 wrote:
admin wrote:Update of my state of mind:

I will get myself a completely new computer with Win7 Prof 64, plus a bag of drugs to get through installing and configuring about 200 softwares. :mrgreen:
I'm not equipped to give pharmaceutical advice, but as far as processors are concerned it might be useful to get one with Intel's or AMD's hardware virtualization feature. Microsoft's Windows Virtual PC requires it and it enables (when run on Windows 7 Professional or Ultimate) running Windows XP Mode, a free and fully licensed copy of Windows XP that's ready to run (no Windows XP setup required).

As far as I know, Intel's Core 2 Duo 8xxx and Quad 9xxx as well as the Core i5 and i7 models support Intel Virtualization Technology; I *think* all of AMD's models support it. My personal preference would be an Intel Core i5 750 or even better, an Intel Core i7 860; unfortunately, processor "fan boys" can make for awkward threads (no pun intended) so I'll leave it at that. :wink:
My current plan is AMD Athlon64 X2 215 AM3. You probably can make it through the German bits: http://www3.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 8&agid=610

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 08:52
by nas8e9
admin wrote:My current plan is AMD Athlon64 X2 215 AM3. You probably can make it through the German bits: http://www3.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 8&agid=610
Assuming it's this one, it does support virtualization.

What would bother me, is the limit of 4 GB; that's pretty much the minimum to use a 64-bit OS. With virtualization added, things can get a bit tight. A motherboard that supports at least 8 GB would allow more headroom. Come to think of it, 6 or 8 GB right now would seem safer and more comfortable to me.

The same applies to the number of internal HD's supported: 2 IDE- (not really the way to connect HD's these days) and 0 SATA-connectors (1 HD and 1 DVD) spare and without specifying how many free internal 3,5" bays, again this would seem limiting to me. It is probably a micro ATX-case.

Just my $ 0,02, mind... :D

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 09:08
by admin
nas8e9 wrote:
admin wrote:My current plan is AMD Athlon64 X2 215 AM3. You probably can make it through the German bits: http://www3.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 8&agid=610
Assuming it's this one, it does support virtualization.

What would bother me, is the limit of 4 GB; that's pretty much the minimum to use a 64-bit OS. With virtualization added, things can get a bit tight. A motherboard that supports at least 8 GB would allow more headroom. Come to think of it, 6 or 8 GB right now would seem safer and more comfortable to me.

The same applies to the number of internal HD's supported: 2 IDE- (not really the way to connect HD's these days) and 0 SATA-connectors (1 HD and 1 DVD) spare and without specifying how many free internal 3,5" bays, again this would seem limiting to me. It is probably a micro ATX-case.

Just my $ 0,02, mind... :D
:) Just keep talking, what you think of this one:
http://www2.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 0&agid=608

BTW, your say " 0 SATA-connectors " but you mean "2"? I don't know much about history, uh hardware, but this is buffling...

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 09:23
by nas8e9
admin wrote: :) Just keep talking, what you think of this one:
http://www2.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 0&agid=608

BTW, your say " 0 SATA-connectors " but you mean "2"? I don't know much about history, uh hardware, but this is buffling...
Sorry, I meant 0 SATA-connectors *spare*: both the single HD as well as the DVD-drive use a SATA-connector.

The processor of this configuration sadly doesn't support hardware virtualization. This configuration from the same site does have a processor with hardware virtualization as well as having room to expand both RAM as well as the number of HD's.

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 11:07
by admin
nas8e9 wrote:
admin wrote: :) Just keep talking, what you think of this one:
http://www2.atelco.de/articledetail.jsp ... 0&agid=608

BTW, your say " 0 SATA-connectors " but you mean "2"? I don't know much about history, uh hardware, but this is buffling...
Sorry, I meant 0 SATA-connectors *spare*: both the single HD as well as the DVD-drive use a SATA-connector.

The processor of this configuration sadly doesn't support hardware virtualization. This configuration from the same site does have a processor with hardware virtualization as well as having room to expand both RAM as well as the number of HD's.
So we are going from 319,00 € to 599,00 €, almost double price for possible extra 4GB RAM and some spare SATA... hmmm, thanks anyway!

Re: OT: Migrating from XP to Win7

Posted: 14 Nov 2009 11:14
by nas8e9
admin wrote:So we are going from 319,00 € to 599,00 €, almost double price for possible extra 4GB RAM and some spare SATA... hmmm, thanks anyway!
I knew there was a problem with trying to spend other people's money... :D

Seriously, I don't know your budget or how long you expect to keep this computer running. I tend to buy every 3-5 years and so I do try to keep an eye on the ability to upgrade the machine. This thread started with your desire to not have to do a reinstall of all your applications; based on that, I'm guessing you'd rather not buy a new machine that often. From the configurations on that site, this was the cheapest while having a processor with hardware virtualization as well as good expandibility.

But yes, almost doubling your budget seems a bit... ambitious. Sorry. :mrgreen: