Page 1 of 2
Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 18:30
by admin
Hey, did you know this (I did not):
http://www.howtogeek.com/howto/7888/how ... windows-7/
Anyway, yesterday when I saw a friend (using XY, of course) manually collecting photo files from a very long list I thought checkboxes would be much cooler here than the usual Ctrl+Click selection or even the Sticky Selection. And even better: what about checkboxes that
remember their state across sessions and across moving the file! In other words: checkboxes that work
like tags (and actually would also use tag.dat). I'm thinking of a separate column called "Tick". The checkboxes would optionally also appear in non-details views, e.g. thumbnails.
Sounds interesting?
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 18:48
by Marco
It surely does!
And I remember this was asked long ago, approx. when you introduced Sticky Selection.
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 18:51
by Slavaon
+1
It is a good idea
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 18:58
by j_c_hallgren
Marco wrote:It surely does!
And I remember this was asked long ago, approx. when you introduced Sticky Selection.
I also remember that it was the topic of at least a couple of 'wish' threads over time...so yes, it does make sense!
Upd/addendum:

Guess what? Seems that this kinda looks like
my old thread:
http://www.xyplorer.com/xyfc/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=4825
There was another one before that one, I believe...
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 19:46
by serendipity
admin wrote:Sounds interesting?
Yes, I am in.
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 20:06
by Filehero
admin wrote:Hey, did you know this (I did not):
Sure, a very handy feature I wish to see in XY besides some others.
Cheers,
Filehero
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 26 Nov 2012 20:49
by admin
Note that my idea is to make the ticks independent of selections (but have a command "Select all Ticked"). If I understand it right, in Windows ticks and selections are always in sync (which I find a rather dumb approach).
You still like it?
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 00:14
by eil
like feature even more with new description.

hope to see some easy way to "select all ticked"(meant some idea for mouse, aside from button).
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 01:29
by PeterH
admin wrote:Note that my idea is to make the ticks independent of selections (but have a command "Select all Ticked"). If I understand it right, in Windows ticks and selections are always in sync (which I find a rather dumb approach).
You still like it?
So after having ticked I must select to select clicked?
(Beg your pardon: after having ticked I must click "Select Ticked"

)
What would I use "the ticked entries" for - if not for selection?
What if I have selected 20 and want to unselect 2: do I have to tick the 2 and select "Unselect Ticked", or so?
Maybe I miss something, but in the moment I don't really understand this differentiating ticked / selected.
(Maybe as I used it a few times in WE...)
Although I must say:
+1

Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 08:02
by admin
PeterH wrote:admin wrote:Note that my idea is to make the ticks independent of selections (but have a command "Select all Ticked"). If I understand it right, in Windows ticks and selections are always in sync (which I find a rather dumb approach).
You still like it?
So after having ticked I must select to select clicked?
(Beg your pardon: after having ticked I must click "Select Ticked"

)
What would I use "the ticked entries" for - if not for selection?
What if I have selected 20 and want to unselect 2: do I have to tick the 2 and select "Unselect Ticked", or so?
Maybe I miss something, but in the moment I don't really understand this differentiating ticked / selected.
(Maybe as I used it a few times in WE...)
Yes, it's a new concept, and I see it can be a little confusing to have "ticked" and "selected" independently.
I just tested how it works in Win7 Explorer. Well, this is not what I want (it's nothing but Sticky Selection with a GUI). But my checkboxes will look the same. More confusion.
Needs more thinking...
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 08:18
by j_c_hallgren
admin wrote:I just tested how it works in Win7 Explorer. Well, this is not what I want (it's nothing but Sticky Selection with a GUI). But my checkboxes will look the same. More confusion.
Needs more thinking...
While it may be true that it's similar to Sticky Selection, I think it's still valuable for: 1) those who may be using it on WE and thus help their transition to XY...2) People who are getting used to that style of slection on smartphones/tablets and find it easy to adapt to...
So...while not having used it more than once on a library PC, I think that implementing it as WE does would still be helpful and thus not confusing.
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 10:33
by PeterH
I still don't understand the advantage of differentiating between checked and selected.
Maybe you could give some hint?
And yes: I'd find the GUI-function (like WE) alone useful.
Maybe, if I would understand, I'd find your expansion even better?
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 10:43
by admin
The ticks would be permanent. You could change folders and come back and the old ticks would still be there. Or close the app and restart.
You could move or rename ticked files and they would keep the tick.
The ticks would have their own column, so you could sort by "ticked". That means you could have a 2-class society of files in every folder, ticked and not ticked.
You could search by "ticked", the whole computer (just like with tags). So you can collect stuff in your whole system, and then, in a milliseconds list it in one search results list.
The ticks would not be affected in any way by (un)selections.
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 11:15
by Marco
So you're basically adding another field to the tag.dat and giving it a meaning. Something like
http://www.xyplorer.com/xyfc/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=8860 .
I know that tag.dat isn't structured with unlimited "fields", but you could merge the ideas.
Re: Tick: Checkboxes for selection
Posted: 27 Nov 2012 11:24
by admin
Yes. And, yes, I could.