Page 1 of 1

Let Google come in?

Posted: 28 Nov 2011 20:52
by admin
Google is blocked from the XY user forum ever since (via robots.txt). I think I should change that. The forum's search functions are so bad... Any objections?

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 28 Nov 2011 22:04
by highend
Internal search function would be good enough if the damn "common words" restriction would be disabled...

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 28 Nov 2011 22:43
by admin
highend wrote:Internal search function would be good enough if the damn "common words" restriction would be disabled...
If I disable it, the search index will become gigantic and searches very slow.

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 28 Nov 2011 23:07
by nas8e9
I wouldn't expect defenders of the built-in search... :)

The only possible downsides I can think of are server and bandwidth load (having the forum become sluggish would be unfortunate), and increased hosting costs. If neither turns out to be a problem: yes please!

I take it you would let only Google in (which would be fine by me)?

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 29 Nov 2011 01:03
by j_c_hallgren
admin wrote:
highend wrote:Internal search function would be good enough if the damn "common words" restriction would be disabled...
If I disable it, the search index will become gigantic and searches very slow.
Can certain selected words be defined as non-common, esp those that may be terms a XY user might look for since they relate to a FM product? Two examples that I found right this moment are "menu" and "tabs" but I've run into a few others that I wish would be indexed...I wouldn't think there's be more than about 20-25 words initially that should be added, if possible, to a "whitelist"...there is NO reason to index non-XY/FM common words but words like "menu" which are common English bit also highly likely to be used by XY forum users should...so for now, I'd think I'd vote to keep Google out IF phpBB can be tweaked a bit,

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 29 Nov 2011 08:20
by admin
j_c_hallgren wrote:
admin wrote:
highend wrote:Internal search function would be good enough if the damn "common words" restriction would be disabled...
If I disable it, the search index will become gigantic and searches very slow.
Can certain selected words be defined as non-common...
No, unfortunately not possible.

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 29 Nov 2011 08:30
by admin
OK, I've let all bots in. Let's see what happens. If problems arise I can always take it back.

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 29 Nov 2011 10:48
by zer0
I would welcome anything that would let script blocks be searchable as they are currently off-limits :( Let's see what the Chocolate Factory would bring us.

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 30 Nov 2011 11:32
by admin
Just saw the Google [Bot] is visiting us. :)

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 30 Nov 2011 12:42
by PeterH
admin wrote:Just saw the Google [Bot] is visiting us. :)
I hope he didn't see me :evil:

OK: sometimes I google - what else. (Used other search engines, but was disappointed after some time.) :cry:
And use Google Maps. Sometimes use OpenStreetMap - but google is better :cry:
I loved Google Earth. But their (forced) update-method was sooo bad that I uninstalled it. :twisted: *I* decide on my PC, not google!

So google is for me like Sony (with all their non-compatibilities): I avoid them when possible.
(With Sony that's quite easy...)

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 06 Dec 2011 17:28
by nas8e9
admin wrote:Just saw the Google [Bot] is visiting us. :)
I'm getting *some* results now from Google search for this forum. It seems adding inurl:xyfc confines the search to the forum like so:

Code: Select all

[searchterm] inurl:xyfc site:xyplorer.com
For people using Firefox, you can define a bookmark and assign a keyword to it. By setting the bookmark's location to:

Code: Select all

http://www.google.com/search?q=%s+site:xyplorer.com+inurl%3Axyfc
...and assigning a keywork like "xy", you can use Google to search only XYplorer's forum by entering this in the address bar:

Code: Select all

xy [searchterm]

Re: Let Google come in?

Posted: 06 Dec 2011 20:00
by admin
nas8e9 wrote:

Code: Select all

xy [searchterm]
Cool trick, thanks!