Page 1 of 2

Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 16:24
by Irwin of Upton
Is there a way to protect a folder from either being deleted or moved but its contests inside remain accessible for all possible file manipulations?

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 17:21
by admin
That would be a case for AccessControl, but this particular thing is not possible yet. Might be an idea for the future. Actually I myself had the desire to do exactly this only some days ago.

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 17:30
by Marco
And, iirc, that was asked also a while ago (and I myself asked the very same thing even before).

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 17:38
by admin
Made a note for 17.00.

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 17:44
by highend
Isn't this something that should be delegated to the NTFS permission system?

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 18:03
by admin
XY's version would be less strict and more portable. Just a quick little safety plus on the road.

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 02 Jun 2016 18:51
by Irwin of Upton
Admin wrote:Made a note for 17.00.
Am greatly pleased to learn it is under active consideration!

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 03 Jun 2016 08:03
by Filehero
highend wrote:Isn't this something that should be delegated to the NTFS permission system?
Exactly my view. Especially in portable mode (on "foreign" machines) it must remain an empty promise, mustn't it? At least, seems to have a high can-of-worms potential. :wink:

But: if it's rather a sort of an "active tag/label" popping up a "You have protected this item!" message (or triggers any other helpful action, e. g. a script :whistle: ), then it is very welcome for me as well.

FH

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 09 Jun 2016 02:53
by eil
Filehero wrote:
highend wrote:But: if it's rather a sort of an "active tag/label" popping up a "You have protected this item!" message (or triggers any other helpful action, e. g. a script :whistle: ), then it is very welcome for me as well.
+1 for this

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 17 Jun 2016 13:33
by admin
Irwin of Upton wrote:Is there a way to protect a folder from either being deleted or moved but its contests inside remain accessible for all possible file manipulations?
Does everybody agree that this is we want certain folders to be protected from?

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 17 Jun 2016 21:21
by eil
i do, as if i understand i still can view folder in flat and make all sublings protected if i need all of them to be.

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 18 Jun 2016 00:24
by tiago
Sure. Preventing deletion of or moving a set of folders around would be key for a successful backup routine I'm about to build on this machine I am.

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 18 Jun 2016 09:37
by admin
But renaming would be okay?

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 18 Jun 2016 10:28
by Filehero
admin wrote:But renaming would be okay?
My wish: no.

For me such a function would offer another - hard - layer of protection to assure that this folder item stays as it is until I decide to change that. If I want to change (rename, delete) it one day, I first have to actively remove the protection.
I would protect all of my backup root directories this way.

Would it support visual/color labeling (a nice overlay icon would be cool eye candy :lol: )?

Cheers,
Filehero

Re: Folder Protection

Posted: 18 Jun 2016 10:32
by admin
Okay, just trying to understand. It's nothing that will come soon. The next biggie is Live Filter Box.