Page 1 of 1

Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 21:59
by taxy
Please consider adding the "Sort Folders Apart" to the feature list at http://www.xyplorer.com/features.php. If this feature had been listed there, I'm positive I would have switched to XYplorer years ago.

You might even want to consider rephrasing the feature, on the features list and in XYplorer itself, because it's somewhat counter-intuitive. When the option is CHECKED folders are not sorted "apart" (from files) in my interpretation. Maybe within XYplorer it could be changed to something like, "Sort Folders With Files" (default as UNCHECKED like it is today) and the feature list could say, "Do not group folders above files"?

I have always hated the way that Windows Explorer (WE) shows the folders first and then regular files below it. Many a time have I cursed the WE programmers, their children, and their children's children. :D It wouldn't have been so bad if WE had an OPTION to turn this off, but as far as I know there never has been one, so thankfully we have XYplorer.

Thanks for listening!

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 22:06
by admin
Really? I would guess that 99% of all users like to have their folder sorted apart from their files. But, of course, my heart it always with the 1% :) (No, I'm not a rocker.)

(I cannot rename it -- it's not worth having 15 translators break their vacation.)

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 00:33
by taxy
(I cannot rename it -- it's not worth having 15 translators break their vacation.)
Sure you could rename it. :D Next time you add a new option to a dropdown menu which will require translations for it, renaming this existing feature would be the perfect opportunity. Or, just rename it in the English version if the other languages already have it clearly "named."

One of the XYplorer selling points for me is this phrase from item #10 on the XYplorer home page:
XYplorer is continuously enhanced and users are taken seriously.
I'm sure you would agree that no one wants to buy a product that seems to have no future so I personally am looking forward to continuous enhancements. :D And of course you aren't saying you'll implement all user suggestions, just that the users will be taken seriously.

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 00:41
by grindax
.

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 05:43
by taxy
grindax wrote: I tried to wrap my mind around how you could be interpreting it, but I could not. To me the name makes perfect sense as it is.
"Apart" can mean "separate" so maybe it would be easier to understand it like this: "Sort Folders Apart" ==> "Sort Folders Separately"

The default of UNCHECKED causes the folders to be sorted separately like Windows Explorer: folders are on top -- separate -- from the files below it.

Usually a feature is CHECKED to enable the functionality. But in this case, CHECKING "Sort Folders Separately" does just the opposite. That's why I wrote that it is counter-intuitive.

If I CHECK "Dual Pane", I get dual panes.

If I CHECK "Show Info Panel", I get the info panel.

If I CHECK "Show Status Bar", I get the status bar.

So why when I CHECK "Sort Folders Separately" does it not do so? It has to be UNCHECKED to "Sort Folders Separately." I don't understand where the unclarity is in the suggestion I'm making.

Renaming it to something like "Sort Folders With Files" would give the same functionality as today, and it would be intuitive: CHECKING the option will mix folders and files. UNCHECKING results in Windows Explorer functionality.
grindax wrote:And I suspect Don is right that the majority of users do choose to sort their folders apart from their files.
I hope that somehow my two suggestions didn't get interpeted as being mixed together -- the above could be a reason not to add the feature to the features list. My suggestion was meant to assist in selling XYplorer. I guess it would be too difficult to add it, or I wouldn't be getting such resistance. :D

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 08:39
by admin
:? In my XYplorer "Sort Folders Apart" has to be CHECKED to sort folders apart from files. And this is the factory default.

I don't think it is a strong selling point that XY allows a mixed sort. Or?

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 09:57
by j_c_hallgren
admin wrote::? In my XYplorer "Sort Folders Apart" has to be CHECKED to sort folders apart from files. And this is the factory default.
Same here -- I don't get why taxy appears to have the opposite. :veryconfused:

I even unchecked my "Sort folders apart" as test and result was folders were mixed into files listing as one would expect...plus the sub-options to that options only make logical sense when folders are not mixed in.

And the name as is makes perfect sense to me....

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 16:15
by taxy
I guess my copy of XYplorer is special. :D

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 16:20
by grindax
.

Re: Add "Sort Folders Apart" to feature list

Posted: 06 Sep 2013 19:09
by taxy
Sure. Here you go.