strongly recommended!

Features wanted...
Post Reply
gohsy
Posts: 1
Joined: 15 May 2011 22:39

strongly recommended!

Post by gohsy »

Increase in multi-language support is strongly recommended, especially to support the Chinese to facilitate the superpowers, China, Hong Kong, Taiwan!

eil
Posts: 1875
Joined: 13 Jan 2011 19:44

Re: strongly recommended!

Post by eil »

first post, "demand", big letters = big mistake.
as far as i know author of XY doesn't want to localize program to any other language. me, personally, think it's not a bad idea.
Win 7 SP1 x64 100% 1366x768|1900x1080

nas8e9
Posts: 2232
Joined: 21 Jun 2008 14:50

Re: strongly recommended!

Post by nas8e9 »

as far as i know author of XY doesn't want to localize program to any other language.
For reference. In short: probably never. Longer version as I understand it: English generally makes for the shortest words and phrases, which saves UI real estate. Other languages, German (the developer's native tongue) in particular, take up far more space.

Even if capable native speakers were to produce translations to the same standard as the English one (which would be difficult to impossible to check for the author in many cases), XYplorer's UI would still have to be adapted to accommodate the longer text. Also, XYplorer grows very quickly which means translations would have to be actively maintained, checked and incorporated.

At this point the fact that XYplorer is a one-man business, i.e. only one person does planning, development, marketing, sales and support, comes into play. Adding incorporating translations to that already over-long list, isn't something the author will do as it will affect the most important item on the list: development. Based on forum requests and the developer's posts on the subject, it would be a commercial advantage to have translations available, but it would detract from XYplorer itself.

admin
Site Admin
Posts: 66366
Joined: 22 May 2004 16:48
Location: Win8.1, Win10, Win11, all @100%
Contact:

Re: strongly recommended!

Post by admin »

nas8e9 wrote:
as far as i know author of XY doesn't want to localize program to any other language.
For reference. In short: probably never. Longer version as I understand it: English generally makes for the shortest words and phrases, which saves UI real estate. Other languages, German (the developer's native tongue) in particular, take up far more space.

Even if capable native speakers were to produce translations to the same standard as the English one (which would be difficult to impossible to check for the author in many cases), XYplorer's UI would still have to be adapted to accommodate the longer text. Also, XYplorer grows very quickly which means translations would have to be actively maintained, checked and incorporated.

At this point the fact that XYplorer is a one-man business, i.e. only one person does planning, development, marketing, sales and support, comes into play. Adding incorporating translations to that already over-long list, isn't something the author will do as it will affect the most important item on the list: development. Based on forum requests and the developer's posts on the subject, it would be a commercial advantage to have translations available, but it would detract from XYplorer itself.
Thank you! I will keep this reply ready for copy+paste.

Post Reply